The table below maps each RFI question to the recommendations that address it. Questions marked No response are outside my direct experience.
Appendix A: Question Cross-Reference
| Question | Recommendations |
|---|---|
| SA-1 | X4 (modularity misuse; replaceability test) |
| SA-2 | X3 (frameworks vs delivery conditions) |
| SA-3 | C2 (flexibility and waiver front door); X3 |
| SA-4 | S7 (production-like testability as definition of done) |
| SA-5 | S2 (lead time to learn); S8 (fund small); X7 (assessment at ATO) |
| SA-6 | S3 (responsive standards function); S10 (learning slices); C2 (participation in delivery) |
| SA-7 | S1 (horizons model; decommissioning as outcome) |
| SA-8 | S1 (workforce learns by shipping); S10 (skills built inside slices) |
| SA-9 | S7 (accumulated test data and interfaces); S9 (person identifier) |
| SA-10 | S5 (challenge-based procurement); S2 (lead time); S8 (fund small) |
| SA-11 | No response |
| SA-12 | No response |
| SA-13 | No response |
| SA-14 | No response |
| V-1 | X5 (upfront correctness); X6 (COTS as lever) |
| V-2 | S5 (low-barrier continuous competition) |
| V-3 | S6 (performance filtering); S7 (test capability); C1 (certification evidence from working systems) |
| V-4 | S5 (vendor engagement through demonstration) |
| V-5 | S6 (value relative to cost, tracked as trendlines) |
| V-6 | X4 (replaceability test); C3 (IP and open publication) |
| V-7 | X7 (assessment at ATO; open adversarial review) |
| V-8 | No response |
| V-9 | S4 (AI-built software); S6 (AI and proposal signal collapse) |
| V-10 | S2 (lead time); S10 (slices); X5 (upfront correctness) |
| V-11 | No response |
| SE-1 | S4 (build economics); X6 (COTS assumptions) |
| SE-2 | S3 (responsive standards function); C2; X1 |
| SE-3 | S10 (standards from cross-domain slices) |
| SE-4 | S1 (Horizon 2 minus pattern); S10 (environment absorption); X1; X2; X5; X6 |
| SE-5 | C1 (trendline outcome measures); X2 (service-level outcomes) |
| SE-6 | No response |
| SE-7 | S3 (consent designed at the point of work) |
| SE-8 | S4 (standards lifecycle vs product landscape); X3 (living standards vs documents); X7 |
| SE-9 | S9 (anonymous person identifier; login.gov) |